PIP Tutorial for Small Business: How to Run a Performance Improvement Plan

Q: What should you not put in a PIP?

Do not include subjective language like 'bad attitude' or 'does not seem motivated' without specific behavioral examples. Do not include personal characteristics or anything that could be interpreted as discriminatory. Do not set goals that are impossible to achieve within the timeframe. And do not reference previous informal conversations that were not documented, as this creates inconsistency between what you say happened and what the record shows.

Q: What is the difference between a PIP and a write-up?

A write-up (formal written warning) documents a specific incident or policy violation and places it on record. A PIP is broader -- it addresses ongoing performance gaps, sets forward-looking improvement goals, defines a support plan, and establishes a structured review period. A write-up is typically a single document. A PIP is an active process with check-in meetings, documented progress, and a defined outcome. Most progressive discipline processes use write-ups before escalating to a PIP.

PIP tutorial - how to run a performance improvement plan step by step

Share LinkedIn Facebook

A performance improvement plan is one of the most mishandled processes in small business management. Most managers either avoid it entirely -- hoping the performance problem resolves itself -- or rush through it incorrectly, creating legal exposure and destroying whatever trust remained in the relationship. Both failures cost the business more than the original performance problem did.

Done correctly, a PIP is a structured, documented, time-bounded process that gives an employee a genuine opportunity to correct their performance while creating a clear paper trail for the business. This tutorial walks through every stage: when a PIP is and is not appropriate, how to write one that holds up legally, exactly what to say in each conversation, how to run the check-in meetings, and how to close the process whether the employee succeeds or fails. Always consult your employment attorney before initiating a PIP, as requirements vary by state and employment type.

What a PIP Is and What It Is Not

A performance improvement plan is a formal document that identifies specific, measurable performance gaps, defines what improvement looks like within a defined timeframe, outlines support the company will provide, and states the consequence if improvement does not occur. It is a process, not a form. The document is the record of the process -- the process is the series of conversations, check-ins, and documented observations that actually happen over the plan period.

A PIP is not a punishment, a formality before a termination you have already decided to make, or a way to build a file on an employee you want gone. Using it that way is both ineffective and legally risky. If you have already decided to terminate someone, a PIP used as pretextual documentation for that decision is far more dangerous than a straightforward termination with a documented business reason. A real PIP is a genuine attempt to help the employee succeed. If that is not your intent, you need a different process.

A PIP is also not the first step in addressing performance issues. It should follow documented informal coaching, at least one formal written warning for the specific issue, and a clear communication to the employee that their job is at risk. Dropping a PIP on an employee who had no prior warning and no documented coaching creates serious legal exposure and is virtually impossible to defend.

When to Use a PIP vs Other Options

Situation	Right Tool	Why
First-time minor policy violation	Verbal warning, documented	PIP is disproportionate for a first offense
Repeated minor violations after verbal warning	Written warning	Escalates the record without the full PIP structure
Ongoing performance gap after written warning	PIP	Formal structure appropriate, pattern is established
Single serious misconduct (theft, harassment)	Investigation then termination	PIP is not appropriate for serious misconduct
New employee struggling in first 90 days	Coaching and additional training	Too early for formal PIP; support first
Role mismatch, not performance failure	Role reassignment conversation	PIP cannot fix a structural fit problem

Step-by-Step PIP Tutorial

Step 1

Build the Documentation Foundation Before Writing the PIP

Before you write a single word of the PIP document, gather your evidence. Pull time tracking records, attendance logs, output quality data, customer complaint records, missed deadline documentation, and any prior written warnings or coaching notes. The PIP must reference specific, dated incidents -- not general impressions. "Employee has missed four project deadlines in the past 60 days" is defensible. "Employee seems disengaged and does not meet expectations" is not.

Every claim in the PIP document needs a corresponding record. If you do not have documented evidence of the performance issue, you are not ready to write a PIP. Go back and document what you have observed before proceeding.

Step 2

Write the PIP Document

A complete PIP document contains six components. The performance gap section states specifically what the employee is doing or not doing, with dates and examples. The expected standard section states what the role requires -- not what you want, but what was documented in the job description or prior performance reviews. The improvement goals section lists three to five specific, measurable goals the employee must achieve by the end of the plan period. The support resources section lists what the company will provide -- additional training, manager check-ins, access to tools or coaching. The timeline section defines the plan duration (30, 60, or 90 days) and the check-in schedule. The consequences section states clearly what happens if the goals are not met by the deadline.

Use objective, behavioral language throughout. Document actions and outputs, not personality traits. "Failed to submit weekly reports on time in 7 of the past 8 weeks" is objective. "Has a poor work ethic" is not and will not survive legal review.

Example language for the consequences section "Failure to meet the performance goals outlined in this plan by [end date] will result in further disciplinary action up to and including termination of employment."

Step 3

Deliver the PIP in a Formal Meeting

Have HR or another manager present as a witness. Do not deliver a PIP via email alone or drop it on someone's desk. Schedule a private meeting, state clearly that the purpose is to discuss a formal performance improvement plan, and walk through each section of the document together. Give the employee time to read it. Answer questions factually and calmly. Do not debate the document in the meeting -- the time for the employee to provide input was during any prior coaching conversations.

At the end of the meeting, ask the employee to sign acknowledging receipt. If they refuse, document the refusal with your witness. Provide a copy of the signed document to the employee and keep the original in their personnel file.

What to say when opening the meeting "I want to talk with you about your performance over the past [timeframe]. Based on what we have discussed in our prior conversations and what I have documented, I am initiating a formal performance improvement plan. I want to walk through it with you so you understand exactly what we need to see, what support we are offering, and what the timeline looks like."

Step 4

Run the Check-In Meetings

Check-ins should happen weekly at minimum for a 30-day PIP and at least every two weeks for longer plans. Each check-in has the same structure: review progress against each goal with specific data, note what is on track and what is not, identify any blockers or support needs, and document the conversation in writing immediately after. Both the manager and the employee should know the documentation is happening.

Do not skip check-ins because things seem to be going well or poorly. If an employee fails the PIP and you never held the documented check-ins, the process is incomplete and legally weaker. The check-in record is part of what makes the PIP defensible.

Check-in meeting structure "Let's go through each goal. Goal one was [X] -- here is what the data shows for this week. Goal two was [Y] -- here is where we are. What has been working? What support do you need that you are not getting? I am going to document this conversation and send you a summary."

Step 5

Close the PIP -- Success or Failure

At the end of the plan period, hold a formal closing meeting. Come with the documented data for every goal. Either the employee met the goals or they did not. There is no ambiguous middle ground in a properly written PIP -- the goals were measurable, so the outcome is measurable.

If the employee succeeded, document the successful completion in writing, acknowledge the improvement explicitly, and note that continued performance at this level is expected going forward. Do not treat a successful PIP as the end of the story -- monitor performance for the next 90 days and document that it is holding.

If the employee did not meet the goals, initiate the termination process with your documented PIP record as the foundation. Do not extend the PIP indefinitely. If the goals were not met by the documented deadline, the process is complete and the stated consequence applies.

What to say at a successful close "I want to formally close out your performance improvement plan. Looking at the goals we set, here is where you landed on each one. You have met the requirements of the plan. I want to acknowledge the work you put in to get here. We will continue to monitor performance going forward and I expect this level to continue."

What to say at an unsuccessful close "We are at the end of the performance improvement plan period. I have reviewed the data against each goal we set. Unfortunately you have not met the requirements of the plan. As we stated at the start of this process, the consequence for not meeting these goals is termination. Today will be your last day. HR will walk you through the next steps."

Documentation You Must Have at Every Stage

Stage	Required Documentation
Before PIP	Prior written warnings, coaching notes with dates, performance data showing the gap, job description showing the standard
PIP initiation	Signed PIP document (or documented refusal to sign), witness name and date, copy provided to employee
Each check-in	Written summary sent to employee after every meeting, data against each goal, support offered and provided
PIP close	Written close-out memo stating outcome, final data against each goal, next steps documented
If termination follows	Complete PIP file, termination letter referencing the PIP outcome, final pay documentation per state law

The Mistakes That Get Employers Sued

No documentation trail before the PIP. A PIP that appears out of nowhere, with no prior warnings and no documented coaching, looks retaliatory to a judge or jury. The PIP process must be the conclusion of a documented progressive discipline sequence, not the beginning of one.

Vague or unmeasurable goals. "Improve attitude" and "be more engaged" are not PIP goals. They are unenforceable and subjective. Every goal must have a metric: a number, a percentage, a completion rate, a specific observable behavior. If you cannot point to data at the end of the plan period and objectively determine whether the goal was met, the goal was not written correctly.

Inconsistent application. If you put one employee on a PIP for attendance violations but tolerate the same violations from another employee, you have created a discrimination claim waiting to happen. PIPs must be applied consistently across employees in similar roles with similar violations.

Skipping check-ins. The check-in record is what proves the PIP was an active, good-faith process rather than a pretext. Missing check-ins, especially when the employee later claims they were never told they were not meeting the goals, is a significant problem.

Extending a failed PIP indefinitely. If the goals were not met by the deadline, the stated consequence applies. Extending the plan period repeatedly signals that the stated consequences were not real, which undermines the entire document and suggests the process was not genuine.

No witness at the delivery meeting. Delivering a PIP alone creates a he-said-she-said situation if the employee later disputes what was communicated. Always have HR or another manager present as a documented witness.

How Updoot Supports the PIP Process

The foundation of a defensible PIP is objective performance data. Subjective impressions do not hold up -- documented records do. Updoot generates the time tracking records, attendance logs, job completion data, and payroll documentation that make PIP goals measurable and PIP outcomes provable.

When an employee's PIP goal is "arrive on time for all scheduled shifts during the plan period," the GPS time clock creates a timestamped, location-verified record of every punch that either supports or contradicts that goal -- without any manager having to manually track it. When the goal is "complete assigned jobs by the due date at least 90% of the time," the job management system has the completion record. The data is already there. You reference it in the check-in meetings, attach it to the closing memo, and if it ever goes to a legal dispute, the record speaks for itself.

Frequently Asked Questions About PIPs

What is a PIP in the workplace? ▶

A PIP (Performance Improvement Plan) is a formal, documented process used to address an employee's specific performance deficiencies. It defines the gap between current and expected performance, sets measurable goals the employee must meet within a defined timeframe, provides support resources, and establishes clear consequences if performance does not improve. A PIP is not a punishment -- it is a structured last attempt to help an employee succeed before the business makes a termination decision.

How long should a PIP last? ▶

Most PIPs run 30, 60, or 90 days depending on the complexity of the performance issue and how long it realistically takes to demonstrate improvement. 30-day PIPs work for straightforward issues like attendance or specific task completion. 60 to 90 days are more appropriate for skill-based or behavioral issues that take longer to change. The timeframe should be long enough to give the employee a genuine opportunity to improve and short enough that the business is not in limbo indefinitely.

Can you fire someone who is on a PIP? ▶

Yes, but the process matters. If an employee on a PIP fails to meet the documented goals by the end of the plan period, termination is typically the documented next step. However, firing someone mid-PIP without documented cause, or firing someone shortly after completing a PIP successfully, creates legal exposure. The PIP process exists in part to create a defensible paper trail showing the employer made a good-faith effort to address performance before terminating.

What should you not put in a PIP? ▶

Do not include subjective language like "bad attitude" or "does not seem motivated" without specific behavioral examples. Do not include personal characteristics or anything that could be interpreted as discriminatory. Do not set goals that are impossible to achieve within the timeframe. And do not reference previous informal conversations that were not documented, as this creates inconsistency between what you say happened and what the record shows.

What is the difference between a PIP and a write-up? ▶

A write-up documents a specific incident or policy violation and places it on record. A PIP is broader -- it addresses ongoing performance gaps, sets forward-looking improvement goals, defines a support plan, and establishes a structured review period. A write-up is typically a single document. A PIP is an active process with check-in meetings, documented progress, and a defined outcome. Most progressive discipline processes use write-ups before escalating to a PIP.

Does an employee have to sign a PIP? ▶

The employee does not have to agree with the PIP to sign it. The signature confirms receipt and acknowledgment, not agreement. If an employee refuses to sign, document the refusal in writing with a witness present. A refused signature does not invalidate the PIP -- it just adds a documentation step. Always consult your employment attorney on specific signature requirements in your state.